By Rufa’i Ahmed Alkali, Ph.D.
Introduction
The crisis in the African Democratic Congress, ADC, has generated intense debate since the Federal High Court, Abuja, judgment of 5 November 2026, which invalidated Senator David Mark’s leadership and the decisions taken under it, including the process that produced former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar as its presidential candidate for 2027. Reactions have been swift, with President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the APC and the judiciary as the principal targets.
Such reactions are understandable in the charged atmosphere of Nigerian politics, but they do not reflect an accurate understanding of what produced this crisis. Political emotion cannot substitute for historical fact. The ADC crisis is neither an isolated judicial event nor a ruling-party conspiracy; its origins lie in internal disagreements over leadership, constitutional authority and succession, and in the controversial emergence of a new leadership in July 2025.
The Crisis Did Not Begin in Aso Rock
The ADC crisis predates Tinubu’s election in 2023. Its roots go back to 2022, when disagreements emerged between then National Chairman Chief Ralph Okey Nwosu and aggrieved stakeholders over the tenure of the National Working Committee elected at the August 2018 convention. That tenure was due to expire in August 2022, but an emergency National Executive Committee meeting on 25 August 2022 approved an extension. Members challenged its legality, arguing that the party constitution did not permit NEC to extend officers’ tenure, and the dispute went to the Federal High Court.
The December 2022 Judgment
On 20 December 2022, Justice Binta Nyako delivered judgment in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1541/2022, brought by Kingsley Temitope Ogga and other aggrieved members. The court held that the Nwosu-led NWC’s tenure had expired and that the extension was inconsistent with the party constitution. It nullified the extension and the affected actions of that executive, directed a special convention, and recognised Senator Patricia Akwashiki as national chairman.
That judgment established that the ADC’s problems had reached the courts and involved substantive questions of constitutional compliance. But the 2022 case and the later litigation involving Nafiu Bala Gombe and the Mark-led leadership are separate proceedings: they are historically connected, but the earlier decision did not determine every question arising from the 2025 transition. What is beyond dispute is that the crisis predated the Atiku coalition; neither Tinubu nor the APC created the original dispute.
The Coalition and the Nafiu Bala Question
The second phase emerged in 2025, as opposition figures including Atiku Abubakar, David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola explored a common platform for 2027 and settled on the ADC. Coalitions are legitimate instruments of democratic politics. But adopting a party as a platform is not the same as assuming control of its leadership without due process. A party is not the private property of a founder or political heavyweight; it is an institution governed by its constitution and recognised organs.
When Nwosu and other officers resigned in July 2025, a constitutional question arose: who was entitled to lead the party? Nafiu Bala Gombe, the Deputy National Chairman, maintained that he had not resigned and that the constitution entitled him to assume leadership pending a properly constituted executive. The coalition-backed group instead produced David Mark as Interim National Chairman and Rauf Aregbesola as National Secretary through the party’s 99th NEC meeting of 29 July 2025. Those circumstances became the subject of litigation.
The issue was never whether Mark or Atiku had the experience to lead the ADC, but whether the procedure complied with the constitution and electoral law. Political and legal legitimacy are related but not identical: an arrangement may enjoy the support of influential figures without satisfying the requirements governing the emergence of officers. Nigerian politics suffers from a recurring tendency to confuse influence with institutional authority. A genuine coalition requires consultation and an agreed framework with legacy members, down to state and ward structures, yet the 2025 transition suggested that incoming leaders concentrated on the national leadership without reconciling legacy interests.
The Constitution and the Electoral Act
Every registered party operates under a constitution setting out how officers are elected, vacancies filled, meetings convened and disputes resolved. The ADC controversy raises fundamental questions: what procedure governs a chairman’s resignation, who assumes leadership when the office is vacant, and can interim leaders exercise powers reserved for an elected NWC?
These are not administrative trivia; they go to the heart of internal party democracy. The Electoral Act 2022 provides a statutory framework covering party administration, conventions and congresses, including notice of meetings and INEC monitoring. Parties enjoy autonomy, but not above their own constitutions or Nigerian law. The judiciary should exercise restraint on purely internal party matters while recognising that constitutional compliance and justiciable rights may come before the courts.
The Supreme Court, 30 April 2026
The Court of Appeal had ordered maintenance of the status quo ante bellum, which affected INEC’s treatment of competing leadership claims. The Supreme Court set that order aside and directed that the substantive case return to the Federal High Court for expeditious hearing. It did not determine who was constitutionally entitled to lead the ADC; it cleared the way for the trial court to do so. Those who celebrated the April ruling as a conclusive settlement did so too early.
The Judgment of 5 November 2026
Justice Peter Lifu, in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025 brought by Nafiu Bala Gombe, upheld the plaintiff’s claims, declared the Mark-led leadership unconstitutional and invalid, and voided its actions and decisions, including those relating to internal electoral processes and the nomination of candidates for 2027, thereby affecting the primaries that produced Atiku and other candidates. The defendants had argued that the suit concerned a party’s internal affairs; the court determined the substantive issues.
A judgment of a competent court carries legal consequences unless set aside by a higher court, but delivery is not immunity from appellate review. By 6 November the party had filed a notice of appeal and an application for stay of execution, which had not been determined when the week closed.
Atiku and the Political Calculation
Atiku Abubakar is among Nigeria’s most experienced politicians: former Vice-President, serial contender and veteran of major realignments, though criticised for taking wrong decisions at the right time and right decisions at the wrong time. The coalition had alternatives, including the SDP and an entirely new party, but chose the ADC.
That was a political decision with profound consequences. The question is whether sufficient attention was paid to the ADC’s existing leadership disputes, constitutional arrangements and the interests of established stakeholders. A party already experiencing prolonged internal disagreement presents obvious risks for any merger. Those risks should have been assessed before it became the foundation of a national project. It is simplistic to blame every subsequent difficulty on external interference when the disagreements were public record.
Where Do Tinubu and the APC Come In?
A divided opposition presents fewer challenges to a ruling party seeking re-election. But being a potential beneficiary of another party’s crisis is not the same as creating it. The ADC’s disagreements predated this controversy: the 2022 litigation arose from disputes over tenure and constitutional authority; the 2025 litigation from questions of succession, the 99th NEC meeting and the emergence of the Mark leadership. Unless credible evidence shows that Tinubu, the APC or any institution engineered these developments, attributing the entire crisis to the ruling government is indefensible.
That does not mean allegations of interference should be dismissed; across Africa they are common, even where unsubstantiated. Nigeria needs a strong opposition, but protecting opposition parties must not shield them from their constitutional obligations. The same standards must apply to all.
Lessons and Conclusion
Parties must be built around institutions, not personalities; a party dependent on a founder or financier is vulnerable whenever leadership changes. Internal democracy must be respected: members are stakeholders, not spectators. Coalitions must rest on genuine consultation. And the judiciary must be protected from partisan pressure, its decisions respected while remaining open to appellate scrutiny.
The ADC crisis did not begin with Tinubu, with the APC, or with the judgment of 5 November 2026. Its origins lie in internal disagreements, beginning with the Nwosu tenure controversy in 2022 and extending to the contested succession of 2025; the litigation followed from those disputes.
You may support Atiku, oppose Tinubu, sympathise with Mark or back Nafiu Bala. These are legitimate preferences in a plural democracy. But preference should not prevent us from examining facts and demanding accountability from all actors, and criticism of a judgment must not be confused with hostility to the judiciary. The test of any decision is the law, the evidence and the reasoning; where error is alleged, appeal is the remedy. Allegations of interference require evidence, not assumptions about who benefits.
Democracy is sustained not by personalities, crowds or campaign funds, but by institutions, constitutionalism and the rule of law. This controversy is not simply Tinubu versus Atiku, APC versus opposition, or politicians versus the judiciary. It is a deeper question about the nature of political parties, the limits of influence and the supremacy of constitutions. Nigeria’s democracy deserves nothing less.
I rest my case.
Rufa’i Ahmed Alkali, Ph.D. is a Professor of Political Science, former Pro-Chancellor and Chairman of Council, Federal University of Technology, Minna, and National Chairman, National Movement for Tinubu–Shettima 2027 – Forward Nigeria.










